Monday, February 14, 2011
Wednesday, June 16, 2010
Plan Be

The War Cry (March 13, 2010, p.4) provided the following review of Dave Andrews’s book:
Why don’t the major world powers do something about all the injustices in the world: the wars, poverty and trafficking? This is the question Andrews posits to start, but he quickly segues by arguing the best thing we can do is to ourselves be the change we want to see. He uses the teaching of Jesus’ beatitudes to advocate living revolutionary lives of mercy, generosity, patient suffering and so on. It is a brief and often political book but a great starting place and a perfect resource for a youth study group.
The War Cry (June 5, 2010, p. 12-13) has provided small group study questions in the first of a series on the above book.
In addition to the small group study questions, I had a few ideas for pondering in response to reading the book.
Dave Andrews’s Plan Be discusses The Sermon on the Mount.
Consider Andrews’s thoughts on meekness (pp. 22-30).
Andrews suggests that great things can happen as a result of a cumulative effect of lots of little people doing lots of little things to change the world. What are some social justice actions that provide examples of this principle?
What aspect of the “upside-down society” (Andrews, p. 12) changes the way we view the world?
What could be some implications of peacemaking using Andrews’s perspective (pp. 54-58).
Compare the differences and similarities in the mercy rule in major religions (Andrews, p.39).
How do the “transforming initiatives” (Andrews, pp. 50-51) relate to unresolved social issues today?
Andrews quotes Mahatma Gandhi, “We must be the change we want to see in the world” (p.69). Andrews suggests that when the Sermon on the Mount is “translated into action, the ideals become ideas that work; a divine agenda for radical – yet viable – personal growth and social change which enables us to work towards the realisation of our dreams for a better world” (p.67). Identify ways to be the change we want to see using the Sermon of the Mount as our realistic ideal.
Letter From The Author
Before he died, Kurt Vonnegut, the famous satirical American author, wrote: "For some reason, the most vocal Christians among us never mention the beatitudes. But - often with tears in their eyes - they demand that the Ten Commandments be posted in public buildings. And of course that's Moses, not Jesus. I haven't heard one of them demand that the Sermon on the Mount, the beatitudes, be posted anywhere." I think its time we took up Kurt’s challenge, and posted the Be-Attitudes up everywhere we can. I am mindful of how Luther’s nailing of his theses for reform to the door of his church led to the reformation of his times; and am of the mind that by posting a copy of the Be-Attitudes up not only in private spaces – like on the back of our bedroom door – but also in public spaces – like on the front of the door to our church, might lead to a new, more radical, reformation - which not only preaches grace as a precept but practices it as a process.
Imagine what could happen if, instead of merely reciting our creeds, which (by and large) have little ethical content, we began every week by reciting - and reflecting on - the Be-Attitudes, with a focus on Christlike ethical responses? Imagine what could happen if our churches, temples, synagogues, and mosques, were transformed into spirited support groups that were committed to helping people live out the Be-Attitudes as an integrated step program? What AA groups have done for our addiction to alcohol, Be groups could do for our addiction to status and violence. They could set us free to ‘love our neighbours as ourselves.’
Dave Andrews
Retrieved from http://www.daveandrews.com.au/
Thursday, May 27, 2010
Monday, May 24, 2010
cycling with sally
"We (Roland and Belinda) began our epic journey together in July 2009, when we started heading south on a tandem bike (Big Bird) from Prudhoe Bay, Alaska. Our goal is to cycle approximately 30,000km through Pan-America and ultimately end up in Usuhuia, Argentina. We hope to complete it in one year or so. We have teamed up with the Salvation Army with the intention to donate our time and hands-on service to any current project they already have running in communities we are passing through. We are thrilled to have this opportunity to work alongside the Salvation Army and believe to will add a very unique and rewarding perspective to our journey."
See http://www.cyclingwithsally.com/
Wednesday, May 12, 2010
Thoughts to ponder
“For what you see and hear depends a good deal on where you are standing; it also depends on what sort of person you are.” C.S. Lewis, The Magician’s Nephew.
1. “We look at the world through the lens of our assumptions and we interpret what we see according to those assumptions” (Allpress & Shamy, p.9). Can you identify a time when you lacked a sense of perspective and mistook an “insect” for a “buffalo”?
2. “Everybody has a worldview, and that worldview is complex and constantly open to revision by the world around us….all worldviews are embedded in stories….Our very identities are caught up in these stories” (Allpress & Shamy, p.10). In the context of chapter two and the idea of the “true story,” what does it mean that “once you learn to read, you will be forever free?”
3. “…this tapestry of stories comes together in cultures…smaller stories piecing together into large, overarching narratives” (Allpress & Shamy, p.11). What “echoes and surprises” have you encountered as you have formed a larger picture from smaller stories?
4. “True stories teach us to see the world differently. And great stories, the ones that claim to tell the true story of the world, compel us to enter in, to become part of the story, and in doing so, they change the way we view the world” (Allpress & Shamy, pp. 19-20). What do you think it means to become part of the story?
5. “How a story begins is always important. The beginning introduces the audience to the main characters, the scene and the main themes of the plot” (Allpress & Sharmy, p.25). How does the beginning represent the rest of the elements of the Narrative such as the theme, the plot, the characters and the scene?
6. “There are two ways to tell the story of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz…the Wizard will solve all their problems… (or) the difficulties along the yellow brick road were the means by which the characters achieved their quest. The same story has to be told more than once – forwards from the start and backwards from the end – in order to discover its full meaning” (Allpress & Sharmy, pp.34-35). How does reading “backwards from the end” affect our reading of the story?
7. “The best way to keep an audience waiting at the end of a story is with a cliffhanger. Leave something unresolved. Leave a question hanging. The higher the stakes the longer the audience will wait” (Allpress & Sharmy, p. 54). What question do you think is left hanging?
8. “Now at last they were beginning Chapter One of the Great Story…in which every chapter is better than the one before” (C.S. Lewis, The Last Battle). “Narrators who tell stories with two ends do so to drive home the reality that the two ends are more than compatible, they are the same… The end looks both similar to and different from the beginning” (Allpress & Sharmy, p.66). Chapter six is entitled “Peering through a crack in time and space”. What would you think is similar and different about the endings?
9. Allpress and Sharmy invite readers to imagine themselves as part of the story (p. 76). Chapter seven begins with a quote suggesting we may not have gone where we intended, but we end up where we needed to be (Adams). How does this relate to your experience of your life’s journey?
Tuesday, May 11, 2010
Bla, Bla, Bla: Part III
I discovered this "marriage" of the Word with action-orientated words from Martin Luther King:Wednesday, May 5, 2010
Book club: The Insect and the Buffalo

by Roshan Allpress and Andrew Shamy
Do we see an insect or a buffalo - our worldview determines what we see. Allpress and Shamy’s book creates a framework for approaching Narrative Text. It invites the reader to consider issues such as perspective, overarching narratives, themes, plot and cliff-hangers – thereby providing opportunity to revise our understanding of what we see. The first chapter can be downloaded from the following site.
http://www.compass.org.nz/ib/home
Monday, May 3, 2010
Blah, Blah, Blah:2

Jesus Christ, is, in the imagery of John 1.14, the Word of God incarnated in human flesh. He is the Revealed Word who moved into a Galilean neighbourhood and learned to speak Galilean, the Word embodied, reframed and translated into publicly intelligible words.
There is our challenge, our hope and what we should be doing with our time!
Friday, April 30, 2010
Blah Blah Blah
Meaning is the extent to which words are embodied.
So what of a blog on social justice? Words are cheap in cyberspace: they are disembodied ideals that float through pixels on anonymous screens without real authors or readers.
And in reading about social ideas and needs, in writing articles that discuss and evaluate, we are given the illusion that we are doing good. But my neighbour is still a bitter cat lady, I still seek value and identity in buying CDs and books, and thousands of kids are still going to die today of starvation.
"A protest is no longer an act of defiance but a confirmation that one’s democracy is functional. Everyone’s political appetite is satisfied – hawks fight a futile war overseas while liberals fight a futile war against that war from the comfort of their laptops."
We protest against social injustice 'here', along with countless others who are a mere click away (to the column on your right for instance). Is this just a cultural placebo to keep us quiet, for both myself as author and you as reader?
At the end of the day, you probably don't know me, and I probably don't know who you are, or if you read this. There is no accountability to real meaning in action.
Maybe we need to pursue more face to face conversation, where our words will be made meaningful through real relational encounters. Where we won't be 'free' to write esoteric and romantic rants that we don't believe in (and therefore don't act upon) because we will be challenged by those we share our lives with, who know us.
So who knows you, and who will recognise the meaning in your words?
Friday, April 23, 2010
The Empire
Monday, April 19, 2010
The Raising of New Public Stories?

David Tacey in Re-Enchantment (2000, p.242) comments:
Wednesday, April 14, 2010
practising values
There are all kinds of social justice activities in New Zealand that give us the chance to practise positive values by contributing to global needs. Another is Oxfam’s Biggest Coffee Break May 1 – 16 to raise awareness of Fair Trade. (See http://www.oxfam.org.nz/index.asp?s1=what%20we%20do&s2=issues%20we%20work%20on&s3=fair%20trade&s4=coffee%20break )
Friday, April 9, 2010
Capitalism vs. Grace
Our whole western society seems to be built around the idea that humanity is self-centered and independent.
Our science says "Survival of the fittest."
Our advertising says "You only get out what you put in."
Our religion says "What you reap is what you sow."
We operate out of our idea of 'justice' - that a person gets what they deserve, whether that be through good actions that leads to reward or through bad actions that lead to punishment. We're responsible for our own skins. Individualism.
So our identity was in what we produced (what we do), and now is more in what we consume (our rewards for what we do). At a party, we ask "What do you do?" and "Have you seen that movie/read that book/been to that place?". That is how we identify ourselves. Do we have inherent worth?
Church plays this game as much as anyone. Religion is about individual performance ("Am I sinning?") and consumption (entertainment-driven church services and youth groups etc.). We are plagued by guilt and fear over whether we're "good enough" to have God's forgiveness...
We are too self-obsessed.
So what is grace? What does it look like in our society?
Wednesday, April 7, 2010
Business as usual?
Tuesday, March 30, 2010
sustainability of the land
This belief in the value of the land as a gift on loan requiring our careful guardianship rings true to me. It seems wise to leave our future generations an inheritance of a plentiful sustainable land.
Williams, J. (2004). Papa-tūā-nuku. Attitudes to land. In Ki Te Whaiao. An introduction to Māori culture and society. Ka’ai, T., Moorfield, J., Reilly, M. & Mosely, S. (Eds.). New Zealand: Pearson Education.
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
more on values

This is a photo from Greg Williams, Oxfam, from an Oxfam article Make Trade Fair The Issue, 2005.
Wallis in his Values book mentioned that Bono, lead singer of U2, donated two autographed T-shirts to Wallis’s wife for an auction (p.166).
Again, I came across reference to Bono on the Sojourner’s site, where he had commented on Wallis’s book God’s Politics.
"The Left mocks the Right. The Right knows it's right. Two ugly traits. How far should we go to try to understand each other's point of view? Maybe the distance grace covered on the cross is a clue."
It made me reflect on the concept of values as a moral compass. It is the worth we place on something. If we value something we hold it in respect and treasure it. We put a price on it. Wallis’s book shows us social justice is to be respected, treasured, invested in, and practised.
For example, when I went on Bono’s web page I saw the value he places on social justice. He travels to Third World countries, connects with aid agencies doing relief work (World Vision), performs benefit concerts for Amnesty International work, campaigns for Greenpeace, promotes Fair Trade products, raises money to fight AIDS, TB and malaria, and lobbies to reduce Third World Debt in the poorest nations. See more information by following this link http://www.atu2.com/band/bono/
In the book U2 on U2 Bono speaks of his heart being “broken” by the everyday tragedy in Africa – the “waste of lives and opportunity”. He speaks of the large amounts of money loaned to African nations during the Cold War by the richest nations. “We were keeping entire countries in debtors’ prisons. The injustice of it really struck a chord with me. It wasn’t a charity-based idea, it was a justice-based idea. .. dropping debts…an historic act of grace that would provide a fresh start for a billion people living on less than a dollar a day.”
My thinking about actions Bono is taking in social justice is helping me frame my own response to Jacob’s question. What are values? They are the things we do. Where do they come from? They come from conscious choices. Who decides what values are important? We do in our everyday decisions. This is on one level. There are also macro levels where other people’s decisions govern our lives, such as Africa. The concept of “historic acts of grace” being shown at an international level is a powerful one.
Tuesday, March 16, 2010
Further reading on values
Wednesday, March 10, 2010
"Values"
Who decides which values are important? Is there only one "moral compass"?
Are we suffering from a lack of values, or a lack of morality? Or because of some particular values and systems of morality?
"Who gets to narrate the world?" - Robert E. Webber
Tuesday, March 9, 2010
Book club discussion questions for "Rediscovering Values".
Wallis suggests for some time we have asked the wrong questions such as: what’s the fastest way to make money? Ads suggest dubious answers to our needs. Instead of the question when will this crisis be over? the question to ask is how will this crisis change me? (p. 2-3). Can you identify any priorities, successes measures, ways of conducting business, and self-regulation that changed as a result of the economic crisis – nationally, locally or in your household? Can you identify any signs of social change or personal change that you feel has come out of the crisis?
Wallis refers to Gandhi’s Seven Deadly Social Sins (p.4) as diagnostic of our current crisis. One of these is wealth without work. How do you interpret this in your social context? What does this mean? Can you give an example?
On page 16 and 17 there is reference to two markets, one of which is the “real market occurring in the back room … this weird Wall Street side bet”. This is compared with the concept “wealth is work” (Stewart, cited on p. 17). Does this value go far enough in your opinion?
Roosevelt is quoted as saying “the measure of restoration lies in the extent to which we apply social values more noble than mere monetary profit” (page 18). What specific social values do you think could help to restore society?
What do you think of the concept that our good is tied up in the common good? Wallis argues that “caring for the poor is not just a moral duty but part of our own enlightened self-interest” (p.23). Provide an argument in support of or in opposition to this view.
“When good people are in a bad system those good people start making bad decisions” (p.136) is a quote from the book. Economically, those trusted with other people’s savings were not thinking about decades later but about the next day’s trade. This short term thinking is contrasted with Native American thinking that considers the impact of decisions for the people and the land for the next seven generations. Identify some “seven generations” thinking and some “next day’s trade” thinking and compare the effect.
What is your response to the idea on page 139 that love for our neighbours and love for the planet on which our neighbours live cannot be separated?
Wallis says that who children admire is important because it affirms and shapes a particular set of value. Celebrities are role models for good or ill and therefore we need more of them to be heroes (p.144-145). Who are the celebrities and the social heroes that you and your family members admire and why?
Detroit is written as a parable of urban depression and economic suffering resulting from broken and unsustainable social contracts (pp. 201-215). However, it also shows community restoration. What meaning can you find in this parable? How relevant is this city to your city? What parallels can you draw?
There are twenty moral exercises given in the final chapter (pp. 227-240). Select twenty ideas to practise over twenty days to deliberately apply the principles of this book. Tell about what worked for you and what was challenging.
For further book club questions, and an interview with Jim Wallis go to the following website:
http://books.simonandschuster.com/Rediscovering-Values/Jim-Wallis/9781439183120/reading_group_guide
Tuesday, March 2, 2010
Book club - Rediscovering values

Jim Wallis’ book challenges the reader to consider social areas edited out of our lives. They are bits of biblical text about responsibility to the poor, and doing what is right based on moral values.
The book highlights these neglected bits of text in context of the present economic crisis. The author uses the city of Detroit as a parable and discusses the concept of “recovering the Commons”.
The author has twenty “moral exercises” which I thought useful for any reader wishing to engage in a practical response of inserting the text back into the “incomplete document”. Individuals or study groups could pick twenty actions to perform as a practical response. I liked the way the book did not leave the readers at Wall Street, but took them back into considering their own street. As a result, it is highly relevant to everyone.
Friday, February 26, 2010
A new direction

The Just Comment Blog is going in a new direction and having something of a rethink. We’re changing the direction of the current page from a random drop-by-and-dump-your-comments-kind-of-place to a new kind of Blog that involves more community interaction and shared learning. There will be two immediate changes. Starting in March we’re going to create a conversational book-club that will for a month at a time engage with a chosen book to see what it can say to our movement. You're invited to read along with us and drop in your comments - reflections on what we're saying or thoughts the book might have stirred in you. A small group might want to consider the conversational book-club as something good to frame and fuel discussion. Throughout the alternative months we will be posting interviews of people involved at the coal-face, stories of people who have committed themselves to the pursuit of social justice. We’re hoping that these new directions will serve you better, prove to be deepening and sustaining and make it possible for even more people to become involved in our conversations.
The book of March is…
Jim Wallis, 2010, Rediscovering Values – A Moral Compass for the New Economy.
Thursday, February 11, 2010
A Road to Recovery

The latest State of the Nation report from the Social Policy and Parliamentary Unit is available online at http://www.salvationarmy.org.nz. It is entitled A Road to Recovery and continues to track some of where our nation is and is not progressing.
Friday, January 29, 2010
Relational Time

Wednesday, January 27, 2010
Standing for and with
The alternative we've inherited from Scripture and from the early days of The Salvation Army compel our movement and our faith to be framed by what we stand for and, dare I say it, more importantly, who we stand with. What could this mean for where you're at? What could this mean for the people who you share a neighborhood with? What does it really mean to be in solidarity with the poor? Is that still how we think of ourselves? Is that what people actually see in us? Monday, January 25, 2010
The NEXT 365

A couple of disquieting and hopeful little thoughts that I'm going to carry with me wherever I go in 2010:
Friday, December 18, 2009
Climate change?
With all the sudden interest in the enviroment, there are some issues that must be addressed.
Is this goin to create further inequality between the rich and the poor, where developing countries and poor people are made to carry the burden created by 20% of the world.
Poverty is linked to the exploitation of earth and even the entire system of how the world operates. If we are unable to care for others, then how are we able to care for earth. We need to make sure those who should be held accountable are. We need to ask questions such as who really is goin to benefit and do I trust what I am being told. Doesn't the entire way we live have to change.
Everyone has the freedom to make choices with where they are placed in this world, you can choose to do the best you can with the life your've been given. Every small but significant act counts, simply by reducing, reusing and recycling adds up. Everyone can make a difference and everyone should say that they done what they could. A question to ask yourself, is what attitude do you carry, victory or defeated.
Tuesday, December 8, 2009
Copenhagen - Real or Scaremongering?

The Copenhagen Summit on Climate Change has started and will no doubt dominate our news media for the next fortnight (unless of course there is something more newsworthy from the camp of Tiger Woods). What do you make of it? Is it simply a lot of career-making scientific scaremongering or is it a real issue of justice (present and future) that we should engage with?
THE SALVATION ARMY AFFIRMS THAT WE MUST ADOPT LARGE SCALE AND PERMANENT CHANGES IN ATTITUDES AND BEHAVIOUR TOWARDS GOD’S CREATION. IF WE FAIL TO DO THIS,WE RISK THE LIVES OF THE WEAKEST AND MOST VULNERABLE — ESPECIALLY CHILDREN AND THE ELDERLY.
The Salvation Army believes that, as people made in the image of God (Genesis 1:27), we have a responsibility to use the resources of the earth in a way that ensures that people in this and future generations do not suffer from poverty or injustice. This is part of our stewardship of the earth and our love of others. In the modern world, Christian stewardship implies large-scale and permanent changes in attitudes and behaviour towards God’s creation, so that we begin to “replenish the earth” (Gen. 1:28).
Responsibility was given to humanity to “cultivate and keep” the earth (Gen. 2:15), but humanity has destroyed or is destroying much of God’s creation (Isaiah 24: 4,5).
God’s instruction to “subdue” the earth and “rule” over every living thing (Gen. 1:28) cannot be interpreted to justify exploitation. God gave His people rights and privileges, but these included duties and responsibilities.
Given the finite resources of the world and its expanding population, together with the impact of industrial and rural activities, development must take account of the need to preserve the earth — an exercise in responsible stewardship.
Therefore Salvationists believe the following principles:
- concern and regard for all life forms, not only human life
- a striving for a more responsible lifestyle in order to do less damage to the environment
- investment in regeneration, taking a long-term view rather than short-term xpediency in thought and action
- care for those who become the victims of the need for environmental stewardship, or who are the victims of environmental vandalism.
Salvationists are encouraged to consider seriously their personal responsibility for the environment by taking practical steps to regenerate and conserve God’s creation" (Cited at http://www.arrcc.org.au/).
What is your take on Climate Change? Is it changing how you live, work and worship?
Wednesday, December 2, 2009
A Christmas that Transforms

Friday, November 27, 2009
Buy Nothing Day - UK - Saturday November 28th 2009
It's sad that even on public holidays shopping malls are open and the many many people you see in them. Wouldn't it be great if one day a week, shops weren't allowed to open.
Tuesday, November 24, 2009
The Social Report

The Ministry of Social Development has released its Social Report for 2009. The Report charts something of how our country is faring. It is a good, and at times disquieting read. See the Report at http://www.socialreport.msd.govt.nz/.
Monday, November 16, 2009
Excising Excess - what do we pay for our drinking?

